feat: deprecate the remove_task command #574

Closed
opened 2025-10-14 16:03:19 -06:00 by navan · 0 comments
Owner

Originally created by @turbobeest on 6/7/2025

In cursor, Gemini 2.5 Pro decided that remove_task was an acceptable taskmaster command to use after multiple task completions. This was a first for me and it seemed to be a pretty odd choice since status changes such as blocked, cancelled, deferred, and (most importantly) completed are much better options. Given the need for a historical record, an audit trail, a knowledge base, and metrics, I suggest purging the remove_task entirely in place of an archive command.

*Originally created by @turbobeest on 6/7/2025* In cursor, Gemini 2.5 Pro decided that remove_task was an acceptable taskmaster command to use after multiple task completions. This was a first for me and it seemed to be a pretty odd choice since status changes such as blocked, cancelled, deferred, and (most importantly) completed are much better options. Given the need for a historical record, an audit trail, a knowledge base, and metrics, I suggest purging the remove_task entirely in place of an archive command.
navan 2025-10-14 16:03:20 -06:00
Sign in to join this conversation.
No labels
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:installation
area:installation
area:installation
area:installation
area:installation
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:vscode-extension
area:vscode-extension
area:vscode-extension
area:vscode-extension
area:vscode-extension
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
help wanted
help wanted
help wanted
help wanted
help wanted
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
integration request
integration request
integration request
integration request
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
low-priority
low-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
provider:anthropic
provider:anthropic
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:gemini-cli
provider:openai
provider:perplexity
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
refactor
refactor
wontfix
wontfix
wontfix
wontfix
wontfix
wontfix
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: github/claude-task-master#574
No description provided.