feedback: Limit the rules somewhat #618

Open
opened 2025-10-14 16:05:22 -06:00 by navan · 0 comments
Owner

Originally created by @bieblebrox on 6/2/2025

Feedback Summary

When initialising my project, a whole bunch of rules were added to an existing repo, first of all it added rules for cursor, windsurf and roo, not everyone uses all three. On top of that the rules added to my cursor where very verbose and several files were added. I'm not sure if all of those rules would be strictly necessary and some things might bloat the context a bit too much.

User Context

Initialising task master on an existing project

User Impact

Feeling a bit overwhelmed by all the new files added

Suggestions

Allow the user to select which tools they use, and give the user more insight into the rules being added to cursor.

Relevant Screenshots or Examples

Not applicable

*Originally created by @bieblebrox on 6/2/2025* ### Feedback Summary When initialising my project, a whole bunch of rules were added to an existing repo, first of all it added rules for cursor, windsurf and roo, not everyone uses all three. On top of that the rules added to my cursor where very verbose and several files were added. I'm not sure if all of those rules would be strictly necessary and some things might bloat the context a bit too much. ### User Context Initialising task master on an existing project ### User Impact Feeling a bit overwhelmed by all the new files added ### Suggestions Allow the user to select which tools they use, and give the user more insight into the rules being added to cursor. ### Relevant Screenshots or Examples Not applicable
Sign in to join this conversation.
No labels
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:ai-models
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:cli
area:installation
area:installation
area:installation
area:installation
area:installation
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:mcp
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:task-management
area:vscode-extension
area:vscode-extension
area:vscode-extension
area:vscode-extension
area:vscode-extension
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
bug
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
documentation
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
duplicate
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
enhancement
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
feedback
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
good first issue
help wanted
help wanted
help wanted
help wanted
help wanted
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
high-priority
integration request
integration request
integration request
integration request
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
invalid
low-priority
low-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
medium-priority
provider:anthropic
provider:anthropic
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:claude-code
provider:gemini-cli
provider:openai
provider:perplexity
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
question
refactor
refactor
wontfix
wontfix
wontfix
wontfix
wontfix
wontfix
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: github/claude-task-master#618
No description provided.